Far-east Java

The island of Java (population 145 million, 2015) can be divided into approximately twenty millispheres. Starting at the far eastern end of Java, it takes the Indonesian regencies of Banyuwangi (1.6m), Situbondo (0.7m), Bondowoso (0.7m), Jember (2.4m), Probolinggo (1.1m) and Lumajang (1.0m) to make up the millisphere of Far-east Java (7.8m).

In 2012 my travel companion and I journeyed from Jakarta to Surabaya during the month of Ramadan. From Surabaya we went by train to Probolinggo and then took a taxi-van up the Tengger volcanic complex to see Mt Bromo, which had last erupted only the year before. Around the caldera rim, growing in the grey volcanic ash, strawberries, onions and cabbages thrived at high-altitude.

Tourist numbers had climbed back to their pre-Bali bombing highs. In 1996-97, before the Asian financial crisis, tourist visits to Bromo peaked at 130,000; during 2001-02, after the Bali bombing, numbers had dropped to 45,000.

These volcanoes, which includes Semeru, the highest mountain in Java, are home to about 100,000 Tengger people. This ethnic group share the same Hindu religion as the people of Bali and had been driven into the hills by the arrival of Muslim Madurans in East Java in the nineteenth century.

The Tengger people have coped with the arrival of the tourist hordes by writing their own development plan, enforced by community law. No land can be sold, or leased for more than a year, to outsiders and the Tenggerese handle all the transport, accommodation and catering. Every morning the mass descent into the caldera and across the sea of sand, in the dark, to observe the sunrise on the volcanoes may seem chaotic but the Tenggerese are in control and the environmental impacts have not been all bad. Tourism has resulted in higher incomes for the Tenggerese, who can now afford LPG and kerosene for cooking instead of cutting their forests for firewood.

Sandwiched between the island of Bali and Mount Bromo, Far-east Java tends to be a place tourists pass through and it is less crowded than the rest of Java. The highway wound through what appeared to be national parks. Coffee trees and workers huts shared the park with the flora and fauna, with no clear separation between conservation and the economy. Beside the road women turned tobacco leaves drying in the sun.

We had planned to meet up with friends in Bali, but we were running ahead of schedule, so we rested up in Kalibaru, a small town, a short trip away from the Bali ferry terminal at Banyuwangi.

Beside the busy highway we found an unprepossessing motel which backed onto rice paddies and coconut palms. By a spreading Banyan tree we discovered the motel swimming pool, fed by a freshwater spring. Apart from a few frogs we had the unchlorinated pool to ourselves.

After a couple of days almost everyone in town had waved to us, and, between swims in “our” pool, we’d managed to have a close look at Kalibaru’s market and eateries and at the coffee, cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves growing outside town.

On the day that we decided to make a dash for Bali and the rendezvous with our friends we discovered that it was also the end of the post-Ramadan holiday week and public transport was crowded with Indonesians returning to work.

When the train pulled into Kalibaru it became apparent that there wasn’t any space for two more travellers. A baggage car at the end of the train had a door open and there were people inside. Boarding from the tracks posed a problem. Pushing my travelling companion up lacked decorum but I doubted if any of the stunned Indonesians would ever see us again.

At the far end an agitated guitar player sat on a piece of cardboard; most buses and trains in Java had travelling buskers. Uniformed train conductors appeared occasionally to shout abuse at the glaring guitarist, who had cleary transgressed.

Still recovering from the ignominy of her entrance my travelling companion sat sulking on her baggage, but a little while later we were crossing the narrow strait to Bali and joining the tourist hordes.

Bali

Millisphere, n. A discrete region populated by roughly one thousandth of the total world population; a bit over seven million people (but anywhere between 3.5 and 14million will do); a lens through which to study human geography.

When I first sat down and divided the world into millispheres Bali was just under my cut-off limit of 3.5 million people. Now, a decade later, Bali’s population stands at nearly 4.5 million. Indonesians coming to take advantage of Bali’s inexorable growth in tourism have been the main driver of this recent population spurt.

Before 1963 there were only three hotels in Bali. In 1963 President Sukarno (who was Javanese but whose wife was Balinese) built the Bali Beach Hotel in Sanur (the first hotel on Bali’s South Coast).

During the 1960’s hippies, travelling by bus, train and ferry through Indonesia, discovered Kuta Beach before there were hotels there, staying in Losmans (traveller accommodation, usually attached to a the family home). These days Kuta Beach is lined with concrete hotels, not dissimilar to Australia’s Gold Coast.

In 1970 the international airport was built near Denpasar, opening the floodgates to national and international tourists. Bali now receives over 3.5 million foreign tourists and 5 million Indonesian tourists every year, but it has come at a cost to their environment.

Bali is still rated the highest for water quality of all of Indonesia’s 33 provinces but because of overexploitation by the tourism resorts 200 out of Bali’s 400 rivers are dry before they reach the sea. On the Bali’s South Coast, where most of the five star hotels and million dollar mansions are, there are now water shortages.

The profligate use of water in the tourist resorts stands in marked contrast to the Balinese Subuk water management system. Developed in the 9th century, the Subuk irrigation system is a complex, pulsing ecosystem administered by the priests from Bali’s Hindu temples. Based on a triumvirate of humans, earth and gods the Subuk system starts with the management of the forests where the waters originate. The water then flows through canals, tunnels, weirs, villages and temple water-gardens before supplying 1200 collectives, of up to 500 farmers each, with water to irrigate their rice terraces.

Tourists, with their natural suspicion of Third World water, demand their drinking water in plastic bottles, which end up in the 20,000 cubic metres of rubbish produced by the tourist resorts of Bali every day. Seventy-five percent of Balinese rubbish dumps are “informal” and during the rainy season plastic discharges into the sea and washes up on the tourist beaches.

It is estimated that, for every one foot (300mm) of coastline in the world, three singlet bags full of plastic rubbish ends up in the sea every year. Last year on holiday in Northland I discovered a line of multi-coloured plastic particles along the high tide mark all the way up the West Coast above Auckland.

From the 24th to the 27th of February this year the World Ocean Summit was held in Bali to discuss, amongst other things, the amount of plastic waste that ends up in the sea. Optimistically subtitled: “bridging the gap between sustainability and economic growth,” this talkfest was held in the five star Nusa Dua Beach Resort on Bali’s South Coast. Their topic for discussion could equally have been: “are we part of the problem?”

Enjoying their time in Bali’s tropical paradise were business leaders, representatives from the United Nations, NGOs and governments and a handful of academics. Eighty-six percent of them came from North America and Europe with only ten percent from the Asia/Pacific (many of the rivers of Asia are clogged with plastic). Fully ninety-six percent of the attendees surveyed said that the conference had been enjoyable and “very useful”.

We tourists are not the only ones to blame. Not too long ago most of the rubbish we humans produced was organic and biodegraded. Now plastic is everywhere and it’s hard to buy even the simplest food item that doesn’t come on a styrofoam tray and wrapped in polythene.

Once, while waiting to board a plane at Denpasar International Airport, I idly counted the number of times the plastic wrapping machine went around a suitcase belonging to one of a group of chattering Australian tourists – it was an astonishing seventeen times.

Eavesdropping I learned that the Australians had enjoyed their time at Kuta Beach. “Jeez we had fun, got peesed every noight,” one said … leaving the locals to pick up their empties and their rubbish.